Loading the Elevenlabs Text to Speech AudioNative Player...

BlackRock, Vanguard, and State Street have become some of the most powerful shareholders in corporate America. Through index funds, they now own roughly a quarter of the average S&P 500 company. Those massive stakes give the trio a powerful weapon: the ability to vote against those companies’ directors.

This, regulators have assumed, is what gives the Big Three their outsized influence over public companies. A new study co-authored by Wharton professor of finance David Musto argues something quite different.

The working paper, “Control Rights or Wrongs? The Content and Consequences of Big Three Engagement,” says the Big Three influence companies less through pressure than through persuasion. Their huge size gives them a front-row seat and a low-cost way to see how thousands of companies are governed, helping them spot what works and then spread it elsewhere.

From Musto’s perspective, that conclusion is deeply ironic. “From an academic’s point of view, indexing is a big success story,” he said. “Investing in index funds has always been one of our main prescriptions — a way to avoid expensive stock picking and be diversified.”

Index funds simply buy and hold the companies in a stock market index such as the S&P 500, rather than trying to beat the market. Their low costs have attracted trillions of dollars from investors.

But that success has spurred a concern, Musto said, that index investing has concentrated corporate ownership in the hands of a tiny number of huge asset managers.

And as funds get bigger, they become cheaper to run. Lower fees attract more investors, making the biggest funds bigger still. “And they have a big chunk of each stock. In the U.S., a quarter, if not more, is owned by the Big Three. That’s a lot of governance in those hands,” Musto warned.

“Pressure has been the focus of regulatory attention.”— David Musto

How the Big Three’s Influence Really Works

The question is how that influence is actually exercised. To find out, the researchers surveyed dozens of corporate secretaries and other senior executives at publicly listed U.S. companies about their dealings with the Big Three and active fund managers too.

Musto said regulators have largely assumed index funds influence companies through the threat of their voting power. “Pressure has been the focus of regulatory attention,” he said, adding that comments from BlackRock chief executive Larry Fink “are not a million miles from that.”

Concentration of ownership brings access. And that can diffuse good governance practices. “If Vanguard calls, the board will take that meeting,” Musto said. “And they can learn something from one company and share it with another. There’s an economy of scale in that sense. Governance is reasonably exportable.”

The evidence in the paper — co-authored with Anne M. Tucker of University of Georgia School of Law and Begum Ipek Yavuz from McGill University’s Desautels Faculty of Management — suggests that advantage is real. But it has real limits, too.

The researchers found virtually no evidence that index funds succeed in getting companies to take more climate action, beyond increasing disclosure. Of the companies surveyed, 31% of respondents said that the Big Three led them to disclose more about climate-related risks, while 24% reported greater disclosure of greenhouse gas emissions.

But only one company changed its climate policies after engaging with the fund managers, and none said they changed the way they ran their business.

Those funds had far more success when it came to diversity: 20% of respondents said engagement with the Big Three led to a more diverse board, 17% reported a more diverse workforce, and 7% reported that they increased diversity in management after such engagement.

“They can learn something from one company and share it with another. There’s an economy of scale in that sense. Governance is reasonably exportable.”— David Musto

The Role of Index Investors

The results suggest the funds work best on issues that cut across companies, where lessons from thousands of boardrooms can be put to use elsewhere. They struggle on issues that can’t simply be carried from one company to another, such as climate policy, where solutions are specific to each firm.

The findings also challenge some common assumptions about stewardship.

Compared with active investors, the paper finds, the Big Three meet fewer companies and spend less time with them. But when they do, they’re more likely to bring along governance specialists and meet directly with company boards. That reflects the governance strength but limited resources of the Big Three.

The study finds active and index investors have settled into different roles. The latter concentrate on governance — issues such as board composition, executive pay, and shareholder rights. Active investors, by contrast, are more likely to push companies on strategy, operations, financial performance, and capital structure.

The research also gives some weight to one of the biggest criticisms of index investing. Company executives were significantly more likely to describe the Big Three’s stewardship as “check-the-box” governance than that of active investors. Yet the survey found also that, on governance issues such as board diversity, the Big Three still deliver solid results.

The Regulatory Dilemma

That brings us to the regulatory question. In 2025, the U.S. markets regulator, the SEC, broadened its definition of investor control, meaning routine engagement with companies could force large index managers onto a more burdensome disclosure regime.

And if the higher costs and more red tape mean they withdraw from engagement, does that risk throwing the baby out with the bathwater?

Musto argues that efforts to curb the influence of the biggest index managers do carry a cost. “If you make them step back, you lose whatever you were gaining from learning across thousands of companies,” he said.

Comments

New This Week

Coexisting With AI at Work and Beyond
Podcast

Coexisting With AI at Work and Beyond

November 10, 2026 • 13 min listen

Ethan Mollick, associate professor of management and co-director of Wharton Generative AI Labs, examines how people and organizations can use AI while preserving human judgment, skills, and control.

The AI Regulation Fight Is About Speed. It Should Be About Measurement

The AI Regulation Fight Is About Speed. It Should Be About Measurement

November 10, 2026 • 5 min read

As Washington debates whether to slow AI development, Wharton’s Burcu Esmer and N. Bugra Ozel from the University of Texas at Dallas argue for a standardized, independently verified system to track AI’s harms.

Will Retail Investors Benefit From Accessing Private Markets?

Will Retail Investors Benefit From Accessing Private Markets?

November 9, 2026 • 6 min read

Wharton’s Robert Stambaugh and Luke Taylor find that opening private markets affects firms much more than retail investors.