Former President APJ Abdul Kalam: 'A Leader Should Know How to Manage Failure'

Published: April 03, 2008 in India Knowledge@Wharton

APJ Abdul Kalam was among India's best-known scientists before he became the country's President. An alumnus of the Madras Institute of Technology, he worked for the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) where he helped launch India's first satellites into orbit. Later, Kalam worked on developing missiles and other strategic weapons; he was widely regarded as a national hero for leading India's nuclear weapons tests in 1998. In 2002, Kalam was named the country's President, and he held that position until 2007. During the Wharton India Economic Forum in Philadelphia, Kalam spoke with India Knowledge@Wharton about his career as a scientist, his vision for India's future, and the most important traits for leaders, among other issues. An edited transcript of the interview follows:

India Knowledge@Wharton: Since our publication is called Knowledge@Wharton, could you tell us something about knowledge?

Kalam: I've written a four-line, poem-like thing called "Creativity." It goes like this: "Learning gives creativity. Creativity leads to thinking. Thinking provides knowledge. Knowledge makes you great." I have made at least a million children repeat these lines. I am very happy that Wharton has created Knowledge@Wharton; it's a beautiful idea. My greetings to all of you.

India Knowledge@Wharton: Perhaps we could begin by talking about your own past. You were born in Rameswaram in 1931. What are the biggest differences between India as it was then and India today?

Kalam: Since then I have orbited the sun 76 times. I have seen when I was a young boy the Second World War coming to an end, and the effect of war and injuries. I saw India attain her freedom in August 1947; I saw the economic ascent phase of India [beginning in] 1991. I have worked with visionaries like Prof. Vikram Sarabhai. I have seen the green revolution, the white revolution, and the telecom revolution; I have also seen the growth of information and communication technologies (ICT), as well as India's successes in the space program and self-sufficiency in strategic weaponry. These are some of the things I have witnessed. Of course, we have a long way to go. Since we have to bring smiles to the faces of more than one billion people, we have many challenges ahead. 

India Knowledge@Wharton: After studying aeronautics at the Madras Institute of Technology, you were one of India's top scientists at the Defense Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) and then at the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO). You helped launch several successful missiles, which led to your getting the nickname, "Missile Man." What challenges were involved in getting this program going and leading it successfully?

Kalam: I worked for ISRO for about 20 years. My team and I worked to put India's first satellite into space. Then our team took up the Integrated Guided Missile Development Program. These were youthful teams that worked with me, and they have gone on to take up much larger projects. These in turn have led to great value addition in areas such as technology, infrastructure and, above all, human resources.

One of the important lessons I learned in the space and missile program was not just how to handle success but how to deal with failure. Wharton is in the management environment. I would like young people to understand how they should manage failure. In any project you take up, you will face problems. These problems should not become the captain of the project chief; the project chief should be the captain of the problems and defeat the problems.

India Knowledge@Wharton: You were actively involved in India's nuclear weapons tests in 1998. Could you tell us about that experience and the lessons you learned?

Kalam: The main lesson I learned was how multiple technical teams and departments of the government of India could work together for a great mission as an industrial partnership. It was a great experience.

India Knowledge@Wharton: You are known to be deeply spiritual. Did you ever feel conflicted, or guilty, about developing missiles and nuclear weapons? Why, or why not?

Kalam: I realize that for my country's development, peace is essential. Peace comes from strength -- because strength respects strength. That is how our weaponized missiles were born. You need strength to keep the nation peaceful, so that you can focus on the necessary developmental missions. That is how I see it.

India Knowledge@Wharton: How did you come to become India's President in July 2002? What leadership qualities does one need to lead a country as large, complex and chaotic as India?

Kalam: Well, I won't call India chaotic, because order comes from disorder. That is what is happening now.

I was elected President of India -- from 2002 to 2007 -- through a well-structured election process. Any leadership -- whether it is political leadership or leadership in technology -- requires that the leader have six traits. What are these traits?

First, the leader must have vision. Without vision, you cannot be a leader. Second, the leader must be able to travel into an unexplored path. Normally the tendency is for people to travel along well-laid out ways. Third, the leader must know how to manage success, and even more importantly, failure.

India Knowledge@Wharton: Could you give an example, from your own experience, of how leaders should manage failure?

Kalam: Let me tell you about my experience. In 1973 I became the project director of India's satellite launch vehicle program, commonly called the SLV-3. Our goal was to put India's "Rohini" satellite into orbit by 1980. I was given funds and human resources -- but was told clearly that by 1980 we had to launch the satellite into space. Thousands of people worked together in scientific and technical teams towards that goal.

By 1979 -- I think the month was August -- we thought we were ready. As the project director, I went to the control center for the launch. At four minutes before the satellite launch, the computer began to go through the checklist of items that needed to be checked. One minute later, the computer program put the launch on hold; the display showed that some control components were not in order. My experts -- I had four or five of them with me -- told me not to worry; they had done their calculations and there was enough reserve fuel. So I bypassed the computer, switched to manual mode, and launched the rocket. In the first stage, everything worked fine. In the second stage, a problem developed. Instead of the satellite going into orbit, the whole rocket system plunged into the Bay of Bengal. It was a big failure. 

That day, the chairman of the Indian Space Research Organization, Prof. Satish Dhawan, had called a press conference. The launch was at 7:00 am, and the press conference -- where journalists from around the world were present -- was at 7:45 am at ISRO's satellite launch range in Sriharikota [in Andhra Pradesh in southern India]. Prof. Dhawan, the leader of the organization, conducted the press conference himself. He took responsibility for the failure -- he said that the team had worked very hard, but that it needed more technological support. He assured the media that in another year, the team would definitely succeed. Now, I was the project director, and it was my failure, but instead, he took responsibility for the failure as chairman of the organization.

The next year, in July 1980, we tried again to launch the satellite -- and this time we succeeded. The whole nation was jubilant. Again, there was a press conference. Prof. Dhawan called me aside and told me, "You conduct the press conference today."

I learned a very important lesson that day. When failure occurred, the leader of the organization owned that failure. When success came, he gave it to his team. The best management lesson I have learned did not come to me from reading a book; it came from that experience.

India Knowledge@Wharton: That is a great story; thank you for sharing it.

Kalam: Continuing further with the six traits, the fourth trait is that the leader should have the courage to make decisions. Fifth, the leader should have nobility in management. Every action of the leader should be transparent. And finally, the leader should work with integrity and succeed with integrity.

All the traits apply especially to the President of a country. The President continuously must be in touch with the people. The Rashtrapati Bhavan [i.e., the presidential residence in New Delhi, India's equivalent of the White House] must become the people's residence. When I was President I travelled to every state, cutting across hills, deserts, and seas. I was in touch with millions upon millions of people.

India Knowledge@Wharton: In your vision for India 2020, you envisaged that differences between the urban areas and the countryside would gradually disappear. Could you explain your concept of "PURA" and how that brings about this transformation?

Kalam: The concept of PURA -- which stands for "Providing Urban amenities in Rural Areas" -- is about giving a cluster of villages physical, electronic and knowledge connectivity. The idea is to empower the villagers, so that economic connectivity can emerge. We planned about 7,000 PURAs for the country -- including hill PURAs, coastal PURAs and plains PURAs. I believe that connectivity is the key to bridging the rural-urban divide. The core-competence of the village will enable the production of competitive products for national and international markets. This will lead to rural enterprises which will create jobs in villages and lead to a vibrant economy in India's hinterland. That is how prosperity will emerge in the rural environment.

India Knowledge@Wharton: How can India become energy independent by 2030?

Kalam: Today fossil fuels dominate the energy sector throughout the world. The World Energy Forum predicts that in five to eight decades, the fossil fuels will run out because these sources of energy are not renewable. Also, energy costs will go up. Oil is already at $110 per barrel, and if this continues, this situation will be very tough to manage.

So I set a goal of energy independence for my country. It's a three-dimensional approach. First, we should invest in solar power. Today solar power is not economical because the efficiency of solar cells is just 15% to 20%. So we should use CNT (carbon nano tubes) composites that can increase the efficiency of solar cells to 45% or 50%. Second, we should use nuclear energy, because India has abundant thorium based nuclear reactors. This is definitely a clean solution to energy needs. The third focus area should be bio-fuels, including ethanol as well as bio diesel made from jatropha [a plant that grows in wastelands] and algae. These three initiatives can free India from dependence on fossil fuels. It will also help maintain a clean environment.

India Knowledge@Wharton: In your vision for India's future technology plays an important role. How will social grids -- such as the knowledge grid, the health grid and e-governance grid -- help make India a developed country?

Kalam: The idea is that the knowledge grid empowers the village citizens with skill and knowledge. The health grid brings the super-specialty healthcare that is available in the cities to the doorsteps of rural citizens. And the e-governance grid brings transparent governance to the citizens. All these grids lead to economic growth and social transformation.

India Knowledge@Wharton: During your years as India's president, what was the biggest leadership challenge that you faced and how did you overcome it?

Kalam:  I returned the Office of Profit Bill to the Parliament. The reason was that I felt there was no transparent system for determining whether a post was an office of profit. That was a major decision. I studied the bill and returned it to the parliament for reconsideration. It created its own dynamic, but I felt I did the right thing.

India Knowledge@Wharton: If you could rewind and replay your years as President, what might you do differently? Is there anything you wanted to accomplish that you were unable to do?

Kalam: Last year I came up with an idea: I felt I should power the Rashtrapati Bhavan completely with solar power. For that I worked on a proposal after completing four years of my Presidential term -- and at the beginning of the fifth year. But then the environmental agencies raised a lot of questions. Before I could answer them, my term ended. I would have liked the Rashtrapati Bhavan to be the first home in India to be powered completely by solar energy.

India Knowledge@Wharton: One last question -- you are a gifted poet. Could you please recite some lines of your favorite poem?

Kalam: My favorite poem is "The Vision." I recited it in Parliament, and I will recite it for you.


I climbed and climbed
Where is the peak, my Lord?
I ploughed and ploughed,
Where is the knowledge treasure, my Lord?
I sailed and sailed,
Where is the island of peace, my Lord?
Almighty, bless my nation
With vision and sweat resulting into happiness.

Print Send to a Friend Get PDF of Article

Here's what you think...

Total Comments: 16

#1    Inspired

Every time I read Dr. Kalam's interview I get inspired and motivated. What a great man !!
By: Brags ,
Sent: 01:35 PM Wed Apr.09.2008 - US

#2    Inspiration & Motivation

Kalam is a role model to the country in terms of technology, management and his thoughts. Above all he is a very good human being.
So many managers take the credit away if success comes, but not the other way around. At the same time they don't carry the minimum courtesy to say "sorry" to their team if they are wrong.
No matter who you are, team member, lead, manager, director, the very basic thing is to be a good human being first.
By: Ramakrishna Balla, MindTree Consulting
Sent: 11:23 PM Thu Apr.10.2008 - IN

#3    Leading From the Front

I'm really impressed by Dr. Kalam's idea of a solar-powered Rashtrapati Bhavan. He is leading from the front again.
By: Vikram Bhonsle,
Sent: 03:03 PM Thu Apr.17.2008 - IN

#4    Inspired #2

Again, we learn from Dr. Kalam that people in general will not shake a leader's hand if they cannot see his or her heart. Dr. Kalam speaks from the heart and emphasizes that leadership is a process through which the six traits are manifested.
By: Ahmed Ait-lahcen, Pala Casino Spa Resort
Sent: 12:11 PM Fri Apr.18.2008 - US

#5    True Leader

Dr. Kalam incorporated the best from his career which helped him to evolve spiritual and political thinking with true leadership skills that worked wonders for India.
By: Theju Paul, ElegantJBI / Business Analyst
Sent: 04:46 PM Fri Apr.18.2008 - IN

#6    Inspiration and Motivation

A visionary like Dr. Kalam is a rarity. My take-away from the article is how to handle and manage success and failure. The team surely gets motivated when their leader gives them all the credit for their success but takes all the blame for failures. It motivates people to give 200% to help the cause/project.
By: Ravi Prasad, Tech Mahindra, Sr. PM
Sent: 07:49 AM Fri Apr.25.2008 - IN

#7    What Kalam Taught Me

It was sometime in early 1975. I was a young engineer in ISRO in the Sriharikota projects. I had occasion to meet Mr. Kalam then as he was the project director for SLV. I had gone along with a senior to meet him. It was a short meeting. I was young and brimming with confidence.
At the end of the meeting Mr. Kalam suggested that I read up on some of the technical journals in aeronautics and space research. Many months after the meeting I had the opportunity to update my knowledge by reading the articles he had suggested and I found that my views were changing.
Looking back, I feel that Mr. Kalam could have easily said to my face that I was wrong in my technical analysis and grasp of the problem. But he chose to guide me instead to learn by myself and arrive at the correct approach. This way he did not hurt my ego and taught me a lesson which I treasure. This was the first glimpse of his greatness that I saw.
By: Kalpathy Balan, KNPC
Sent: 12:06 PM Thu May.01.2008 - KW

#8    Six Imperatives of Leadership

After going through the article and the excerpts, I can easily say that Dr. Kalam's views concur with the need of effective leadership.
I would always try to incorporate all the six traits of leadership elucidated by him.
I'm highly inspired and motivated by his views.
By: Ankush Verma, a leader in aspiration
Sent: 02:45 AM Mon May.12.2008 - AU

#9    Leadership

The article is really a wonderful learning opportunity. The six traits of a leader as mentioned by Mr. Kalam would definitely develop a good leader.
By: Abeed Shareef, Leadership
Sent: 03:37 AM Fri May.23.2008 - IN

#10    Brilliant Leader!

A true leader. Kalam is a man of honesty and integrity. Very inspiring!
By: Rajeev Chelikkattil, Melbourne
Sent: 09:49 AM Mon Jun.16.2008 - AU

#11    Thanks for the Inspiring Interview

Kudos to Knowledge@Wharton for providing an opportunity for many to know a bit more about a truly great living person. His poems, clarity of thought and desire for improving humanity come through in this short interview. His greatness gives him a humility that is evident in the video.
By: Ganesh Ram, Mumbai, India
Sent: 01:11 AM Thu Jun.19.2008 - IN

#12    APJ Kalam - The Missile Man, The President and The Role Model

I am speechless! This is truly inspiring...

As a manager, I face a lot of problems in my day - to - day activities. I always wondered what could be the answer be to my problems. Here, in this article...I found it!
By: Divya Tanjore, Aditi Technologies
Sent: 05:20 AM Fri Jul.11.2008 - IN

#13    Great man with Vision

Yes, Mr. Kalam is a great man with a clear vision for India's growth, but I'm not sure how much support he will get from the political visionary people to fulfill his dream for a powerful and strong India. Best wishes to a great man.
By: Jogesh Panda, Infogain Corporation
Sent: 11:06 AM Mon Jul.28.2008 - US

#14    Leadership

The life lessons that former president of India Dr. APJ Abdul Kalam has offered about leadership are great and inspirational. Every person who aspires to become a leader must bear them in mind.
By: Mahesh kumar/, Aristotle Education Alliance Private limited
Sent: 03:07 AM Mon Sep.01.2008 - AU

#15    Creating Millions of Visionary Children

Dr. Kalam has traveled across India to meet with over 2 million schoolchildren. He has initiated each one of those kids to dream and have a "personal vision." He tells the kids, "We are all born with a divine fire in us. All that we need to do is to give wings to this fire and fill the world with the glow of its goodness." He is a living example of someone who practices personal mastery as a leadership discipline and propagates it relentlessly.
By: Manjakkudi Jayaraman, Lumino Strategies
Sent: 01:32 AM Sat Dec.20.2008 - IN

#16    A Man of Immense Faith

I have been lucky to attend one of his speeches at BITS, Pilani. Apart from his technical prowess, what really captured my attention is his immense faith in human potential, faith in the inherent goodness of man, and faith in the spirit of youth. A person of his standing expresses such profound faith in the capabilities of what we can achieve. That is what I find really inspiring.
By: Merrin Kurian,
Sent: 01:28 PM Mon Apr.06.2009 - AU
 

Sign In to Join the Discussion

Email Address:   
Password: 

Not a member?
Sign Up for India Knowledge@Wharton

Tools

Print Get PDF of Article Send a Comment Send to a Friend
Adjust font size:
8pt10pt12pt14pt
Visit the Knowledge@Wharton Network: U.S. | 简体中文(Simplified Chinese) | 繁體中文(Traditional Chinese) | Español | Portuguêse